Someone Gets It Right – The Best Time to Explain a CEO’s Salary Is Before Anyone Asks

A $285,000 salary is the kind of number that can grab some attention, especially when it comes in the educational world. It’s not hard to write a story making that salary sound like money being taken directly out of a classroom. But if you are a board member trying to recruit someone who can do a complex, high-stakes job correctly, it might not seem out of line.

Last month, the Indianapolis Public Education Corporation approved a $285,000 salary for its first executive director, Karega Rausch. IPEC is a new public corporation with responsibility for some consequential and politically sensitive issues involving Indianapolis Public Schools and charter schools. Its executive director will oversee its day-to-day operations, budget, staff and vendors while the organization works on transportation, facilities and a new school accountability system.

I don’t pretend to know the ins and outs of IPEC. I live in Kansas City, and have read about IPEC only because I scan the national news for articles about nonprofit CEOs and their compensation. Even at a distance, it is obvious that there is plenty about IPEC for Indianapolis residents to debate. There already is a vigorous dispute over a property-tax referendum the organization has placed before voters and how the resulting money would be distributed.

I don’t have to be a Hoosier to see that scrutiny is going to be intense. But I don’t need a direct interest to recognize that the board handled one potentially controversial decision extremely well. They just put on a master-class in dousing the flames of discontent before they even started blazing.

They got out in front of the controversy and stripped away any mystery about it.

Months before Rausch was hired, IPEC publicly advertised the position with a salary range of $235,000 to $325,000. The range wasn’t pulled out of the air. The organization said it had researched compensation paid to surrounding school superintendents and municipal corporation presidents. Thirty-six people applied for the job, six finalists were identified, and Rausch was ultimately selected.

Even then, the organization didn’t bury the compensation decision. I love the fact that the range was published ahead of time. I might quibble that the $90,000 range was a bit wide, but it was a new position, and they were wise to make sure they attracted a good range of applicants.

When Rausch was announced as the choice in July, news reports specifically noted that his salary had not yet been determined. A few weeks later, the board publicly approved $285,000 and details of the compensation package were available for reporters to examine. Health benefits, retirement contributions, paid time off,  professional expenses and even a cell-phone allowance were disclosed. They even clarified that there would be no vehicle allowance.

You can argue about whether $285,000 is too much, too little or exactly right. That’s a different question.

What cannot be argued is that the board shined light on the process, which I greatly admire.

Executive compensation controversies often become controversies not simply because of the number involved, but because of the way the number comes to light. Someone hops onto Pro Publica or Candid and prints out a Form 990. A reporter gets a gut feeling that readers might be surprised that somebody working for a nonprofit earns a 6 figure salary. Or a donor discovers a bonus that was never discussed publicly. Or a board member who wasn’t involved in the decision starts asking questions. Suddenly the organization is explaining a compensation decision defensively, months or years after it was made.

That is exactly how even a perfectly reasonable salary can start to seem scandalous. Somebody had to do a little snooping to “uncover” it. Even if that “uncovering” was limited to clicking on a 990 link on the organization’s website.

Transparency doesn’t guarantee agreement with the amount, but it certainly does eliminate the surprise factor.

IPEC provided the salary range before hiring anyone. It described the type of comparative information used to establish the range. The compensation ultimately approved fell right in the middle of the previously announced range. The board voted publicly. The components of the package were available for examination.

None of this proves that $285,000 is the “right” salary. Compensation decisions aren’t mathematical equations with one correct answer. They might have been able to get him for $280,000. Or he might have been able to talk them up to $290,000. Maybe they made him buckle on the car allowance, and maybe he will get lured away next year for a job that offers him a Rolls Royce.

But I think the transparency shows the value of having the explanation available at the same time as the number.

I’m not in Indianapolis, so I don’t know what is being said in coffee shops. From a distance, at least, the compensation decision seems to have generated attention the attention it deserved without becoming a controversy of its own. The salary received considerable news coverage, as a $285,000 public salary probably should. But I have found relatively little subsequent controversy focused on the compensation itself. The more substantial arguments surrounding IPEC have concerned its authority, the proposed property-tax referendum and how that money would be distributed. In other words, the conversation seems centered on legitimate policy issues, not on the CEO’s salary.

There is a lesson here for nonprofit boards. You don’t necessarily need to publish your CEO’s proposed salary in the newspaper before approving it. Frankly, unless there’s something surprising about it, such a press release would go ignored. The IPEC was in a different situation – private nonprofit organizations operate under different rules and circumstances than a public corporation.

But boards should behave as though someday somebody is going to ask how they arrived at the number. For most substantial nonprofits, boards should assume that the CEO’s compensation will eventually become publicly accessible through aForm 990.

What organizations did you compare yourselves with? Why were they comparable? What did those organizations pay? Did independent board members make the decision? Was the full compensation package considered, rather than just salary? Was the reasoning documented when the decision was made?

Those are much easier questions to answer when the board actually asked them before approving the compensation, and documented the answers. Try to step out of your well-informed board member role and think about what a reporter would think, or what your neighbor would think.

A good compensation process shouldn’t be designed merely to withstand hostile scrutiny. It should make sense to an interested outsider, and leave that person understanding how the board got there, even if they might have chosen a different number.

Scroll to Top