Does an Appreciated CEO Really Need a Formal Evaluation?

Many nonprofit board members believe that a strong CEO does not really need much feedback. Everyone likes them. The organization is doing well. The board is pleased. Surely the CEO knows that, right? Probably. But knowing the board is happy is not the same thing as receiving useful feedback.

By all means, compliments matter. A sincere word of appreciation can carry a person for a long time. Mark Twain reportedly said he could live for weeks on a good compliment, and most of us understand the feeling.

A compliment shares appreciation. Feedback says, “Here is what we value most. Here is where we see your strongest contribution. Here is where we think the organization needs your attention next. Here is how you can become even more effective.”

Those are very different messages.

Boards make a well-intentioned mistake when they let appreciation stand in for evaluation. It’s an understandable impulse. They do not want to nitpick. They do not want to create conflict. They may feel that a successful CEO has already earned the right to be left alone.

But a good CEO does not merely want to be liked. A good CEO wants to keep improving. A steady flow of kudos can feel wonderful, but it does not provide direction. “You’re doing great” does not tell the CEO whether the board is most impressed by financial management, staff leadership, fundraising, community relationships, strategic thinking, or crisis management. It does not reveal whether there are quiet concerns. It does not help the CEO decide where to focus limited time, resources, and energy.

A thoughtful evaluation process helps the board say, clearly and respectfully: this is what matters most right now, this is where you are excelling, and this is where we want to support your continued growth. That kind of feedback is not awkward and it is certainly not a punishment. It is a form of partnership.

Boards should absolutely thank their CEOs. They should celebrate wins and notice hard work. But they should not stop there.

A good CEO wants and deserves clear, constructive feedback.

Scroll to Top