Now Is the Time to Start Your Year-End CEO Evaluation

For many nonprofit boards, the annual CEO evaluation begins sometime in December with a sudden realization: We probably ought to evaluate the CEO before the end of the year. If that’s you, congratulations! Instead of a stern lecture about procrastination, you deserve a toast – roughly half of nonprofit boards don’t even do an annual CEO evaluation, so you’re on the right side of that line. Bravo! And you still have time to do it calmly and effectively.

If your organization conducts its CEO evaluation near the end of the calendar year, late October and November are the right time to get started.

To be clear, a helpful and effective evaluation need not take two months. Starting early gives the board time to think about what it actually wants to learn, gather useful feedback and have a meaningful conversation with its CEO before everyone turns their attention to the new year.

Start with expectations, not questions

A good evaluation should not begin with a survey. It should begin with a question:

What did we expect the CEO to accomplish this year?

That sounds obvious, but boards do not always have a clear answer. Expectations may be scattered among a strategic plan, annual budget, board minutes, committee discussions and conversations with the board chair. The expectations might have changed and evolved over the course of the year. Important successes and failures that happened last January may have faded or been forgotten.

Before evaluating performance, the board should identify the most important expectations it established for the CEO during the year. Ideally, these were collected in a document shared at last year’s evaluation and modified as they morphed. If that is your organization, you’re on top of things!

What were the major organizational priorities? Were there particular financial goals? Program objectives? Fundraising expectations? Leadership challenges? Strategic initiatives?

Most CEO evaluations should also address broader leadership responsibilities, including organizational management, financial stewardship, strategic leadership and the relationship between the CEO and the board. Those responsibilities don’t disappear just because the organization established three or four particular goals for the year.

A good evaluation considers both the subjective and objective. It examines the CEO’s general effectiveness as a leader while also measuring performance against the priorities and expectations of the particular organization. Some are going to be measured in checked boxes and some by scales.

And if the board never clearly established those expectations in the first place, that’s worth recognizing. It may be something the board needs to improve before next year’s evaluation.

Ask the whole board

The CEO reports to the board, not simply to the board chair or executive committee. Every board member should have an opportunity to participate in the annual evaluation.

That doesn’t mean every director has the same perspective or the same knowledge of the CEO’s work. A finance committee member may have particularly useful observations about financial leadership. A development committee member may be better positioned to assess fundraising performance. Other directors may have more experience working with the CEO on strategic planning, community relationships or board operations.

Those differences are valuable, provided they are understood. A thoughtful evaluation should allow directors to indicate not only how they assess the CEO’s performance, but how confident they are in those assessments.

A board member who gives the CEO high marks for financial management while acknowledging limited familiarity with the organization’s finances is providing different information from a finance committee member who offers the same rating with considerable confidence.

Both responses deserve consideration, but they shouldn’t necessarily be interpreted the same way. In fact, one of the most useful findings from an evaluation may have relatively little to do with the CEO. If board members consistently lack enough information to assess important areas of organizational performance, that may indicate a problem with board oversight or communication rather than executive leadership.

That’s valuable information that doesn’t get captured in most surveys.

Give people time to think

Board members are volunteers, and December is a busy month.

Sending an evaluation on December 20 with a December 23 deadline so that you can meet with the CEO before the ball drops in Times Square is unlikely to produce particularly thoughtful responses.

Allow enough time for directors to consider their answers, reflect on the CEO’s accomplishments and challenges, and offer useful written observations. Remember that even the most dedicated board members have travel plans, family emergencies and the flu. A survey that takes 20-30 minutes to fill out might take a few weeks to get to.

It’s also important to explain how the information will be used and who will see it. Board members may be more candid when they know their individual responses will be treated confidentially and presented to the board in an organized report rather than attributed to particular directors.

The goal isn’t simply to collect a sufficient number of completed questionnaires. It’s to gather informed, thoughtful assessments from the people responsible for overseeing the CEO.

Look beyond the averages

Suppose a CEO receives an average score of 8.4 out of 10 for strategic leadership.

That’s encouraging, but what does it actually tell the board? Did nearly everyone give the CEO an eight or nine? Or did half the directors give a perfect ten while the other half gave a six? Is there a cluster of very low scores?

Those are very different situations, and they call for different conversations.

Similarly, a CEO who receives uniformly high ratings across every category may still have areas of relative strength and weakness that deserve attention.

A good evaluation report should help the board understand patterns in the responses, differences in directors’ perspectives, the relative importance of particular leadership responsibilities and the level of confidence directors have in their assessments. Written comments can provide valuable context for numerical ratings, especially when they identify particular accomplishments, concerns or expectations.

The point isn’t to reduce a CEO’s performance to a single number. It’s to give the board a clearer understanding of what its members collectively think, where their assessments differ and what deserves further discussion.

Leave time for the conversation

The written report is not the evaluation. It is preparation for the conversation.

Once the information has been collected and analyzed, the board needs time to review the findings, identify the most important themes and decide how to discuss them with the CEO. That conversation should recognize accomplishments as well as areas for improvement, while keeping an eye on the coming year. Even a glowing review should have guidance on how to improve.

The discussion should look to the coming year. What should the CEO’s priorities be next year? What support does the CEO need from the board? Are expectations clear? Are there problems the board itself needs to address?

An evaluation should not be an annual ceremony in which the board tells the CEO how well things went and then files the report away until next December. One of its most valuable results should be a clearer understanding between the board and CEO about the organization’s direction and the executive’s responsibilities for the year ahead.

And then there is compensation

For many organizations, the CEO evaluation occurs near the time the board considers executive compensation.

The two decisions are related, but they are not the same thing.

Performance is one factor a board may consider when setting compensation. The board should also consider appropriate comparable compensation information, the responsibilities of the position, the size and complexity of the organization, and other relevant circumstances.

An excellent performance evaluation does not automatically justify a substantial raise, just as a challenging organizational year does not necessarily mean the CEO performed poorly.

Starting early gives the board time to consider both matters thoughtfully rather than trying to resolve performance and compensation during a single hurried December meeting.

It also allows time to gather appropriate compensation comparisons if the board needs them.

A simple timeline

For an organization planning a December or January evaluation, the process might look something like this:

Late October or early November: Confirm the evaluation process, identify organization-specific goals and expectations, and determine the schedule.

November: Survey the entire board, allowing adequate time for thoughtful responses and follow-up reminders.

Late November or early December: Compile and analyze the responses, identify important patterns and prepare a report for the board.

December or January: Review the findings with the CEO, discuss accomplishments and challenges, and establish expectations for the coming year.

The process may be somewhat different for each organization. Some conduct evaluations based on the fiscal year rather than the calendar year, and some prefer to separate the evaluation from compensation decisions.

That’s fine. The important thing is to establish a deliberate process and follow it.

A brief commercial interruption: If all of this sounds like something your board should do, but nobody particularly wants to organize it, I can help. That’s what NPCEO Evaluation does. We develop customized evaluations, gather confidential feedback from the entire board, and turn the results into a useful report. We also offer CEO compensation reviews. Give me a call at (816) 486-7766 or send me an email at CEO@npceoevaluation.com, and let’s talk about making this year’s evaluation easier for your board and more useful for your CEO.

We now return to our regularly scheduled article.

Make it a routine, not an emergency

An annual CEO evaluation shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone, least of all the CEO. The board should know when it will conduct the evaluation, what it intends to assess and how the results will be used. The CEO should understand those expectations well before receiving the final report.

Ideally, the annual evaluation is part of an ongoing conversation about organizational performance, leadership and the relationship between the board and its chief executive.

Put the evaluation on the calendar. Review the expectations established earlier in the year. Decide how you’ll gather feedback from the full board. Allow enough time to consider the results and have a meaningful conversation. It’s not terribly complicated. It just requires a little planning.

And if your board is planning a year-end evaluation, now would be a very good time to begin.

Scroll to Top